7 min read

TUESDAY BRIEFING: CPUC PD Would Deny Additional PCIA Credit for Pre-2019 RECs

Today's roundup looks at a proposed decision that, if adopted, would reject CalCCA's effort to secure an additional credit for renewable energy credits generated before 2019. The PD finds that their value was already allocated under the former PCIA methodology.

Separately, another CPUC ruling sets detailed requirements for California Climate Credit reform proposals, emphasizing implementable designs and transparent customer-impact analyses.

Additionally, Commissioner Darcie Houck has a new PD that revises the CPUC's Tribal Consultation Policy and Tribal Land Transfer Policy to expand tribal participation in CPUC matters and utility property sales.

BONUS MATERIAL: For those who are interested in the CAISO's Extended Day-Ahead Market, I spoke to Utility Dive for a piece that was published today. Also, over at RTO Insider, I have some news on Ontario's developing approach to data centers.

And for something completely different – I visited Frank Lloyd Wright's Taliesin West last week. Some photos are available here.

-- MC


POWER CHARGE INDIFFERENCE ADJUSTMENT

The CPUC issued a proposed decision in the PCIA and ERRA Reform docket. The PD requires PG&E, SCE, and SDG&E to value renewable energy credits generated before 2019 and banked for later use at zero dollars when calculating the PCIA.

The PD finds that bundled customers already credited departing load for the market value of those renewable resources in the years the resources were generated, under the PCIA methodology then in effect. Because that allocation satisfied the state's customer-indifference mandates when it occurred, requiring a further credit when the utilities later use the banked RECs for Renewables Portfolio Standard compliance would impose a new cost on bundled customers and itself violate those mandates.

The PD rejects the California Community Choice Association's argument that customers who subsequently left bundled service retained a proportional interest in the banked RECs and are owed either a credit at the current RPS market-price benchmark or an allocation of the RECs themselves. Administrative Law Judge Eileen Odell concludes that the newer valuation method (under which RECs are valued when they are sold or used for compliance) applies only to RECs generated on or after January 1, 2019.

The PD also treats CalCCA's claim as untimely, finding it barred by laches. CalCCA acquiesced in the prospective-only reach of the post-2018 rules, and other stakeholders relied on the finality of the earlier decisions when making procurement and market decisions. Correcting a single alleged historical cost shift in isolation, the PD adds, would be arbitrary.

If adopted, the PD's zero-dollar treatment would take effect immediately and be incorporated into the utilities' October updates for their 2027 ERRA forecasts, affecting 2026 true-ups and forecasted 2027 rates.

The earliest the CPUC will consider this item is September 17. Comments are due September 2.

INSTANT ANALYSIS: The zero-dollar treatment does not mean the banked RECs lack compliance value. It means the Commission considers that value already allocated under the pre-2019 PCIA methodology and will not reopen the allocation when the RECs are used. The key dispute is therefore about timing. CalCCA says the cost shift occurs now, when bundled customers receive the compliance benefit; the PD says any defect arose under the former methodology and is now barred by laches.


CLIMATE CREDIT

Administrative Law Judge Maria Sotero issued a ruling establishing requirements for proposals to change the California Climate Credit. The proposals are due September 14.

Proposals may address the timing or number of credit distributions, calculation methodology or customer eligibility and must explain whether changes would vary by utility. Parties also must address:

  • Equal treatment of bundled and unbundled customers;
  • The four priorities identified in the assigned commissioner's June 29 ruling;
  • Equity and environmental-justice considerations; and
  • Why their proposal is necessary and incremental to both the status quo and concepts already raised by the commissioner.

Proposals must provide as much detail as possible about implementation time, cost and complexity, including whether the changes could be implemented by 2028. Parties also must discuss customer communications, potential behavioral effects and any data gathering or collaboration with utilities. Any impact estimates must be accompanied by the underlying spreadsheets or CSV files and source citations.

Parties may, but are not required to, estimate credit amounts and bill impacts or propose changes for master-metered customers. Any impact analysis must hold total distributed allowance proceeds at the amount forecast for 2026, use 2025 recorded consumption data where available and compare the proposal with the existing credit for typical CARE and non-CARE customers across climate zones, for at least one large investor-owned utility or the specific utility the proposal targets.

Parties must meet and confer by August 28. The ruling strongly encourages "office hours" with utility staff. It allows parties to submit data requests, which utilities must answer within 10 business days and circulate to the service list unless the information is confidential.

INSTANT ANALYSIS: The CPUC wants implementable Climate Credit proposals, not merely competing policy concepts. The Commission is not requiring parties to calculate customer impacts immediately, which lowers the barrier to submitting proposals. But parties that provide estimates must disclose their underlying data and hold total allowance proceeds constant. This will allow the Commission to compare how each proposal would redistribute the existing credit rather than obscure the effects through differing revenue assumptions.


TRIBAL POLICY

Commissioner Darcie Houck issued a proposed decision that revises the CPUC's Tribal Consultation Policy and Tribal Land Transfer Policy to expand tribal participation in Commission matters and utility property sales.

The consultation policy would:

  • Require "early, often and meaningful" engagement on actions with tribal implications;
  • Clarify the responsibilities of the Office of the Tribal Advisor and division tribal liaisons; and
  • Let tribes escalate inadequate consultations to the Executive Director.

The office also would maintain a tribal contact list, publish a map overlaying utility service territories and county boundaries, and begin convening quarterly Tribal Information Forums in 2027.

The revised land-transfer policy would apply to all real-property dispositions by covered investor-owned utilities, including surplus property the CPUC might otherwise never review under Public Utilities Code Section 851. Utilities would obtain contacts from the Office of the Tribal Advisor, notify relevant tribes and give interested tribes access to a virtual data room with the property's current appraisal, recorded easements and other information.

Energy utilities would report dispositions quarterly. Disputes among tribes seeking the same property would run first through the tribes, then the CPUC's alternative dispute-resolution program, with the Commission deciding if needed.

The proposal does not extend the policy to telecommunications providers or require utilities to map all their holdings.

The earliest the CPUC will consider this item is September 17. Comments are due September 2.

INSTANT ANALYSIS: Extending the policy to surplus property means tribes would receive notice even when a utility sale requires no Section 851 review. But implementation is dependent on the vacant, governor-appointed Tribal Advisor position. Meanwhile, the PD defers the harder disputes over telecommunications property, tribal taxation, tribal law and energization delays.


NATURAL GAS RESEARCH

Two new draft resolutions would strengthen CPUC oversight of gas research, development and demonstration programs administered by the California Energy Commission and PG&E.

  • Draft Resolution G-3622 would approve in part the CEC's two $24 million plans for fiscal years 2024-2025 and 2025-2026, while requiring the agency to use $31.1 million in previously authorized, unspent funds before drawing additional money from ratepayers. The prior funds would cover the entire 2024 plan and part of the 2025 plan, limiting new ratepayer funding to $13.5 million. The CEC would have 90 days to revise both plans to improve financial reporting, demonstrate coordination with other research administrators and address potential duplication. It also could not fund hydrogen-related research under its 2024 fuel-flexible generation initiative because the CPUC has not determined the appropriate role of gas ratepayers in supporting hydrogen research.
  • Draft Resolution G-3623 would deny PG&E's request to recover $1.95 million for its 2024 plan because the utility had already spent the money without first obtaining CPUC approval. The resolution would not permit another resubmission. It would approve modified budgets of $6.13 million for 2025 and $7.87 million for 2026, subject to revised plans within 60 days. PG&E would need to better distinguish its work from similar SoCalGas research, quantify expected benefits and, for its 2026 artificial-intelligence work, account for energy, cloud-computing, data-storage and processing costs while retaining human decision-making authority.

INSTANT ANALYSIS: Energy Division is establishing a common oversight framework for separately administered gas research programs, with greater emphasis on unspent balances, measurable ratepayer benefits and avoiding duplicative work. The PG&E denial also demonstrates that advance Commission approval is a substantive condition, not a procedural formality that can be cured after money has been spent. SoCalGas reported in June that its four research plans for 2024 through 2027 were awaiting Commission resolution, suggesting these drafts may preview the standards that will be applied to the remaining major gas RD&D administrator.


CALIFORNIA AUGUST 2026 ROAD TRIP PHOTOS