Nov. 19 CPUC Voting Meeting Results: RNG Above-Market Costs Extend to Noncore Customers in 4-1 Vote
Good morning, the table below gives the results of the CPUC's Nov. 19 voting meeting. Summaries follow.
| Item / status | Action | Bottom line |
|---|---|---|
| Regular agenda | ||
| Renewable gas costs 33A · Adopted 4–1 | Reynolds alternate adopted; Houck dissents | Core and noncore customers, including covered entities and generators, pay the same per-therm charge. First workshop on potential relief due within 150 days. |
| PG&E wildfire costs, 2020–22 35 · Adopted 3–1 | $1.768B approved; $477.3M disallowed | Pole and line work drew most cuts. PG&E can’t seek the disallowed unit-cost increases later. |
| PG&E interim GRC rates 32 · Adopted 5–0 | Up to $456M from Jan. 1, 2027 | 55% of requested electric increases and 85% of proposed gas cuts. Any overcollection must be refunded with interest. |
| SB 884 undergrounding 12 · Adopted 5–0 | Cost tests, audits and recovery conditions set | Risk-neutral cost tests for now. PG&E says about 873 of 4,000 miles may qualify. |
| Consent agenda | ||
| Disconnections 36 · Adopted | SoCalGas cap provisionally lifted. Electric utility caps may rise by 0.5 percentage points. | ZIP-code cap cut to 20%. AMP made permanent; PIPP winds down. |
| Efficiency database (DEER) 6 · Adopted | 2028–29 update; 2026–27 values revised | Net-to-gross set at 1.0 for weatherization and CO₂ equipment from 2028. |
| DER avoided costs 7 · Adopted | Calculator principles and equity analysis adopted | Circuit-level reliability report for CARE, FERA and Medical Baseline customers starts in 2028. |
| SDG&E renewable sales 18 · Approved | CCA sales extended to July 2042 | Revenue offsets PCIA. Pricing includes an RPS benchmark adder under review in R.25-05-020. |
| SDG&E green tariff 10 · Adopted | $3.02M recoverable; $1.59M denied | The order and its legal conclusions use different allocation bases. |
| PG&E 2024 ERRA 8 · Adopted | Settlement approved; $296,922 disallowed | Battery dispatch reporting for the top 500 hours starts with the 2026 filing. |
| SFPP oil pipeline 3 · Adopted | Terminals ruled jurisdictional; record reopened | SFPP has 45 days to file terminal data or the record closes. |
| Electric rate design 9 · Adopted | E3 contract extended, up to $700,000 | Public nonresidential bill-impact toolkit; workshop in Q1 2027. |
| Holds and withdrawals | ||
| PG&E / Google 2 · Held to Jan. 14, 2027 | Held by staff | Seventh hold since July for the 250 MW San Jose interconnection. |
| Liberty wildfire costs 31 · Held to Dec. 3 | Held by staff | $58.05M Mountain View Fire recovery, plus financing and some unresolved claims. |
| CEC gas research 4 · Held to Dec. 3 | Held by Houck | Two plans sought $48M. The draft estimates $16.9M in new ratepayer costs. |
| SDG&E / SoCalGas safety costs 34 · Held to Dec. 3 | Held by Houck | $620.6M wildfire recovery, 19% below request. Pipeline safety cut 66% and 85%. |
| SCE Eldorado–Lugo–Mohave 11 · Withdrawn | Withdrawn | Would have raised the project cost cap from $295M to $312M. |
RENEWABLE NATURAL GAS
The CPUC voted 4–1 to adopt President John Reynolds’ biomethane alternate over Commissioner Darcie Houck’s proposed decision. Houck dissented, and her proposal was withdrawn.
The alternate allocates the Renewable Gas Standard’s above-market costs to core and noncore customers, including electric generators and Cap-and-Invest covered entities, at the same per-therm rate through gas transportation charges. Houck would have charged core customers first and considered a later allocation to noncore customers, with covered entities exempt. PG&E, SoCalGas, SDG&E and Southwest Gas have 120 days from issuance to file Tier 2 advice letters.
Reynolds argued that hard-to-electrify industries should share in the program while the costs are still small. Commissioner Matthew Baker asked Houck, “Could you talk a little bit more about why you’re uncomfortable applying this to noncore customers?” Houck replied, “The decision doesn’t say we won’t.” She saw low near-term costs as a chance to spend 18 months assessing the effects on Cap-and-Invest compliance, electric bills and the prices of goods.
Houck cited the compromises the Legislature and governor struck with refiners, warned that importing goods after industrial production moved out of state could add shipping emissions, and said exemptions would be harder to administer once billing began. She agreed with Commissioner Baker that the Legislature was better placed to make the call but wanted to bring attention to unintended consequences.
INSTANT ANALYSIS: Covered entities will pay through transportation rates even if they buy gas from a third party, and utility biomethane purchases leave their own Cap-and-Invest obligations unchanged. The workshop will consider an additional greenhouse gas avoided-cost deduction for covered entities, including the option of doubling the existing deduction, as well as potential relief for emissions-intensive, trade-exposed customers. The first workshop must occur within 150 days of issuance, and the joint utility application is due within 18 months of that workshop, with any relief subject to a separate CPUC decision.