CALIFORNIA REGULATORY INTELLIGENCE
  • Home
  • Pricing
  • Proof of Value
  • What is CRI?
  • Contact Us
  • CPUC Voting Meeting Results
  • Other Media
Sign in Subscribe

Search

POSTS
22 Aug 2026 6 min read PCIA

SATURDAY BRIEFING: PCIA Reform, Data Center Forecasts, and Aliso Canyon

In today's briefing:

  • The CPUC is reopening the structure of the Power Charge Indifference Adjustment even while acknowledging it already satisfies the legal indifference standard;
  • The Commission is forcing PG&E to show how much of its data-center forecast rests on actual commitments rather than earlier-stage interest; and
  • SoCalGas and the Indicated Shippers are asking the Commission to delay the next assessment in the Aliso Canyon Biennial Assessment proceeding long enough to incorporate a still-evolving methodology.

POWER CHARGE INDIFFERENCE ADJUSTMENT

The CPUC has expanded its ERRA/PCIA reform rulemaking (R.25-02-005) into two new tracks. Assigned Commissioner Matthew Baker's second amended scoping memo divides Track 3 into Tracks 3A and 3B, and defines a Track 4.

The proceeding's goals include reducing year-to-year PCIA volatility, improving benchmark accuracy, assigning costs more accurately by resource vintage, and increasing transparency around portfolio costs, to the extent confidentiality rules allow.

Track 3A covers refinements implementable within the existing PCIA structure:

  • Possible changes to the Renewable Portfolio Standard benchmark to reflect longer-term resources;
  • Revisions to the Energy Price Index benchmark to reduce undercollections and rate volatility;
  • Changes to the GHG-free benchmark and allocation methodology; and
  • Clearer rules for "re-vintaging" resources.

Track 3B will examine whether the PCIA (while, as the ruling stipulates, already achieving statutorily-mandated indifference) poses technical, policy, or implementation challenges that justify alternatives such as:

  • Securitization;
  • Mandatory resource allocation;
  • Cost-allocation mechanisms; or rate-stabilization funds.

Track 3B also takes up minimizing excess or uneconomic portfolio costs and market mechanisms to recover and transact the value of new "legacy assets" created through ongoing procurement.

Track 4 addresses:

  • Further benchmark changes;
  • Slice-of-Day treatment in the Energy Resource Recovery Account;
  • ERRA/Portfolio Allocation Balancing Account trigger reforms;
  • Compliance-review standards for Bundled Procurement Plans;
  • Negative indifference calculations; and
  • Other volatility measures.

The ruling also directs load-serving entities to meet and confer on disputed access to utility data within 60 days, with a joint report due within 75 days identifying the requested data, its relevance, utilities' concerns, and possible compromises.

INSTANT ANALYSIS: Commissioner Baker explicitly acknowledges the PCIA has achieved the legally required indifference between bundled and departing customers, then asks whether that same result could be reached through a less cumbersome design. The ruling even raises market mechanisms for new "legacy assets" created through ongoing procurement, an acknowledgment that the portfolio keeps generating them. The frame is not "PCIA may be broken" but "PCIA works legally, so is the structure still worth keeping?"

That makes the data-access dispute more than a procedural sideshow. Community Choice Aggregators say they need more utility portfolio data to build proposals; utilities question the relevance of some requests; and Commissioner Baker's transparency objective is itself expressly limited by confidentiality requirements. The ordered meet-and-confer will help determine how much of the portfolio economics parties can actually see while debating whether to redesign the mechanism built around them.


ERRA/DATA CENTERS

The CPUC issued a ruling that grants a Cal Advocates' motion to compel PG&E to turn over more detailed information about the data-center load embedded in its 2027 ERRA forecast.

Cal Advocates had asked PG&E to break out how much forecast data-center demand comes from projects with signed service agreements, active applications but no agreement, and inquiries that have not yet become formal applications. PG&E resisted on confidentiality and relevance grounds, arguing that Cal Advocates already had aggregated industrial-load information and that the ERRA proceeding concerns the overall load forecast rather than individual customers.

The ruling rejects both arguments. It states that confidentiality does not shield information from Cal Advocates, which has broad statutory authority to obtain confidential material relevant to a Commission proceeding. And it says PG&E should have used the Commission's existing confidentiality protections rather than withholding the information.

The most consequential finding concerns the forecast itself. Cal Advocates argued that it needs to see the assumptions beneath PG&E's data-center forecast to determine whether the emerging load could have an outsized effect on ratepayers. PG&E countered that customer-level detail was unnecessary because the relevant forecast is the aggregate one. The ruling sides with Cal Advocates, reasoning that the CPUC must sometimes look beneath a high-level forecast to test whether its assumptions are realistic. That is notable in this instance because PG&E itself says industrial-load growth is being driven primarily by data centers.

PG&E must provide the fully responsive information by August 31. It must provide within two business days the draft fall-update data-center forecast that it had already offered Cal Advocates during the discovery dispute.

INSTANT ANALYSIS: The CPUC wants to see what sits inside PG&E's data-center forecast before it accepts the number. PG&E said its aggregate industrial forecast was enough. The ruling says it was not, and that the CPUC may have to test whether the forecast data-center load is realistic before relying on it.

A project with a signed service agreement is a firmer forecasting input than one resting on an application, and an application is firmer than an inquiry. That ranking is the point of the three categories Cal Advocates demanded. It lets them measure how much of PG&E's projected growth is committed and how much is speculative.

PG&E has said data centers are now the main driver of its industrial-load growth, and the ruling tied that admission directly to the need for project-level detail. Once a forecast this speculative starts setting rates, whether the underlying projects are real becomes a question the CPUC will want answered.


ALISO CANYON

The Indicated Shippers and SoCalGas are asking the CPUC to move the deadline for the next Aliso Canyon Biennial Assessment Report by one year, from June 15, 2027, to June 15, 2028.

Their petition says Energy Division's first assessment, issued in 2025, recommended a caveated reduction to Aliso Canyon's maximum inventory level, prompting SoCalGas to file A.26-01-009.

That proceeding is now reconsidering both the storage level itself and whether the assessment framework (the inputs, assumptions, and methodologies in D.24-12-076's Attachment A) should be revised to reflect current and reasonably expected future conditions. With hearings possible late this year and briefing deadlines still unset, the petitioners say a final decision is unlikely before 2027.

Their main argument is that retaining the June 15, 2027 deadline would leave Energy Division too little time to incorporate whatever methodological changes emerge from A.26-01-009. The next report could therefore rely on outdated inputs or only partially reflect new Commission guidance. Moving the report to 2028, they contend, would produce a more accurate assessment built on a fully implemented framework while avoiding duplicative litigation over whether the new methodologies had been properly incorporated.

The petition also argues that a 2028 report would better align with other planning and commercial timelines. SoCalGas's current Backbone Transportation Service contracts run through October 31, 2029. The petitioners say a June 2028 report would give market participants relatively current information as they approach the next BTS cycle, rather than relying on a report that could be more than two years old.

The later date would also let the assessment incorporate more information from implementation of Senate Bill 1221's neighborhood decarbonization pilots and from the California Energy Commission's 2027 Integrated Energy Policy Report.

INSTANT ANALYSIS: The filing makes a stronger case for additional time than it does for a full one-year delay. The reason for choosing 2028 becomes clearer in the petition’s discussion of other timelines. SoCalGas’s current BTS contracts run through October 2029, SB 1221’s second-round pilot deadline falls in January 2028, and the CEC’s next full IEPR is due in 2027. A June 2028 report would therefore arrive closer to several decisions that could affect gas planning and contracting.

There is an obvious counterargument if the petition draws opposition. Energy Division already moved the first report from June 15 to October 1, 2025, when it needed more time, and SoCalGas later received a separate extension before filing its application. That history gives the CPUC another option: keep the biennial schedule and grant targeted relief when necessary. The petitioners are asking instead for certainty now, with the next report fixed in 2028 and the two-year cycle resuming from there.

I1702002 Indicated Shippers and Southern California Gas Company Joint Petition for Modification
I1702002 Indicated Shippers and Southern California Gas Company Joint Petition for Modification.pdf
369 KB
download-circle

Published by:

MC

You might also like...

20
Nov

Nov. 19 CPUC Voting Meeting Results: RNG Above-Market Costs Extend to Noncore Customers in 4-1 Vote

11 min read
14
Nov

PD Roundup: RPS Plans, EV Charging Forecasts and Climate Adaptation

6 min read
23
Oct

FRIDAY AGGREGATE: ERRA Updates, Wildfire Math and CRI's 1-Year Birthday

11 min read
16
Oct

SoCalGas Alert: BTS Rate Increase, Biennial Assessment Ruling

4 min read
07
Oct

WEDNESDAY AGGREGATE: PCIA Benchmarks, ERRA Trigger, Grid Modernization

7 min read
CALIFORNIA REGULATORY INTELLIGENCE © 2026
  • Sign up
Powered by Ghost