> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.calregulatory.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# WEDNESDAY AGGREGATE: Competing 2028 LOLE Studies Find CAISO Long on Capacity
- URL: https://www.calregulatory.com/wednesday-aggregate-32/
- Published: 2026-08-19T12:30:09.000Z
- Updated: 2026-08-22T23:56:27.000Z
- Author: MC
- Tags: LOLE, Loss of Load Expectation, BTS, Backbone Transportation Service, Planning Reserve Margin, congestion revenue rights, Distribution Integrity Management Program

Today’s roundup looks at a 2028 CAISO portfolio so well supplied that neither Energy Division nor SCE could produce reliability events without first adding load or removing capacity. 

Today's briefing also examines the CPUC’s first major rewrite of electric utility procurement rules since 2015 and a SoCalGas filing that anticipates decreases for most customer classes on September 1, except BTS customers, whose rates will rise **1.1%**.

---

### RESOURCE ADEQUACY

**Energy Division Draft LOLE Study Finds 2028 CAISO Over-Reliable**

ALJ **Debbie Chiv** attached Energy Division's [draft 2028 loss-of-load-expectation study](https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Efile/G000/M614/K587/614587098.PDF?ref=calregulatory.com) to an [August 17 ruling](https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Efile/G000/M614/K997/614997080.PDF?ref=calregulatory.com) in the Resource Adequacy docket (R.25-10-003). Staff found CAISO's projected portfolio produces no loss-of-load events under base assumptions and could absorb about **6,150 MW** of additional demand while holding near the one-in-10-years standard. The modeling baseline carries about **18,300 MW** more nameplate capacity than the 2026-study baseline, led by storage and solar.

Adding **6,150 MW** of flat demand every month yielded a **0.113** annual LOLE and an unadjusted **21.9%** September Planning Reserve Margin (HE 20). Monthly stress testing produced approximately **25.2%** July - October and **21.8%** otherwise. 

Applying the unforced capacity (UCAP) methodology adopted in D.26-07-008, with forced-outage and ambient-temperature derates, cut those to about **20.5%** and **17%**. Staff also found CAISO stays above standard with imports zeroed out (**0.028** LOLE).

Energy Division has not recommended 2028-2029 Planning Reserve Margins. Its pro-rata capacity-reduction scenario remains unfinished and is slated for discussion at a September workshop. A final study and recommendation are due in October.

**INSTANT ANALYSIS** *:* The draft shows a well-supplied system but stops short of a proposed requirement. The stress-test figures are sensitive to how staff manufactures scarcity: adding demand drained batteries across consecutive stressed days and pushed the modeled summer into October. The UCAP numbers are the relevant benchmark for future requirements: they express the modeled reliability need after resource credits are reduced for expected outages and heat derates.

---

**SCE Study** [**Calculates 16.4% Planning Reserve Margin**](https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Efile/G000/M614/K587/614587075.PDF?ref=calregulatory.com) **for 2028**

SCE independently studied 2028 CAISO reliability and calculated a 16.4% UCAP-based September Planning Reserve Margin. SCE used Energy Division's published resource, demand, weather, renewable, hydro and import assumptions where practicable, but ran them through PLEXOS rather than SERVM.

Like Energy Division, SCE found the baseline portfolio produced no unserved energy. SCE then cut non-hydro resources by about **19%**, held demand response to **1,700 MW**, and reduced peak-hour imports by approximately **19%**. The calibrated portfolio removed **20,935 MW** of nameplate and produced a **0.085** annual LOLE, within standard. Modeled events fell in July-September, mostly HE 16–24, averaging three hours. SCE attributed the rise from its 2026 figure of **15.5%** partly to batteries taking a larger share of the mix.

**INSTANT ANALYSIS:** SCE offers an early result using a pro-rata-style capacity reduction—the general approach Energy Division has not yet completed. Both studies agree the projected 2028 portfolio holds more capacity than needed. The open question is how much can come out while meeting the standard. The nearest published staff comparator is Energy Division's **17.2%** September UCAP result from its flat-load calibration, just **0.8** points above SCE's **16.4%**. Even those figures are not directly comparable because the studies use different models, footprints, case designs and treatments of demand uncertainty. Energy Division's forthcoming pro-rata run will show whether the difference persists when staff removes capacity instead of adding demand.

---

### INTEGRATED RESOURCE PLANNING

For the first time in more than a decade, California regulators are reopening the rulebook that governs how the state's largest utilities buy power.

An [ALJ ruling](https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Efile/G000/M614/K587/614587099.PDF?ref=calregulatory.com) asks parties to weigh proposed updates to the Bundled Procurement Plans of PG&E, SCE and SDG&E. These are the frameworks that, under [Public Utilities Code Section 454.5](https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/public-utilities-code/puc-sect-454-5/?ref=calregulatory.com), let specified transactions clear an upfront standard and win preapproval rather than face reasonableness review after the fact. The CPUC last rebuilt these plans in 2015\. The utilities filed their latest proposals June 1.

At issue is how much contracting the three utilities should be allowed to do without returning to the CPUC deal by deal. Collectively, they seek broader authority over renewable energy credits, resource adequacy, energy, fuel and new CAISO day-ahead products, all to be transacted under the plans' upfront standards. 

- PG&E asks for RPS delivery terms up to five years, RA up to 10 and other electric and fuel transactions up to five;
- SCE proposes parallel authority, RA contracts shorter than 10 years, and the addition of Day-Ahead Market Enhancement products; and
- SDG&E requests preapproval of short-term RPS deals and RA contracts of 10 years or less.

The RPS proposals share a common thread: the utilities want to stop filing a separate advice letter for each transaction and instead report them in batches, after the fact, through quarterly compliance reports. The ruling asks parties to scrutinize the volume limits, price-reasonableness showings and ratable-rate methodologies behind that shift, along with the roles of the procurement review group and independent evaluator. Affordability and ratepayer risk run through every question.

The Commission also poses questions common to all three plans: 

- Whether their RPS frameworks should track the utilities' previously approved procurement plans;
- Whether a standardized method should govern REC purchase and sales limits;
- How the plans should absorb the new unforced-capacity counting framework; and
- How they should treat CAISO's imbalance-reserve and reliability-capacity products, excess RA sales and greenhouse-gas compliance instruments.

The ruling also revisits the 2006 restrictions on utility participation in CAISO's congestion revenue rights auctions, asking whether loosening them would deepen competition and return more revenue to customers.

The three utilities must file a matrix showing where their plans line up and where they differ, and defend each difference. Energy Division will convene a hybrid workshop in mid-September, and parties must attach their workshop materials to their opening comments, which are due **November 13**.

**INSTANT ANALYSIS:** For short-term RPS transactions, the utilities want standing authority with quarterly reporting instead of individual advice letters. Price and volume limits would therefore assume much of the oversight now provided through transaction-specific filings. The congestion revenue rights questions could have the larger financial consequence. The CPUC is reconsidering whether restrictions imposed in 2006 now limit auction competition and reduce congestion revenue returned to ratepayers.

---

### SOCALGAS RATES

SoCalGas submitted Advice Letter 6682-G (file uploaded below) to reduce systemwide gas transportation revenue by **$66.3 million**, or **1.3%**, effective **September 1**. 

The filing removes completed 12-month recoveries for the Distribution Integrity Management Program Balancing Account, Catastrophic Event Memorandum Account and COVID-19 Protections Memorandum Account. It replaces them with a 12-month, **$59.4 million** recovery for the Storage Integrity Management Program Balancing Account. SoCalGas is also recovering **$7.8 million** allocated to it from SDG&E's Transmission Integrity Management Program Balancing Account. Both figures include franchise fees and uncollectibles.

The consolidated update would reduce core revenue by **$55.1 million** and noncore revenue by **$19 million**, partly offset by the **$7.8 million** increase in backbone transportation service revenue. 

- Residential and core commercial-industrial transportation rates: down **1.5%**
- Noncore commercial-industrial rates: down **2.4%**
- Electric-generation rates: down **3.5%**
- Wholesale rates: down **4.7%**
- Backbone transportation service rate: up **1.1%**

Protests are due **September 6**.

**INSTANT ANALYSIS:** The decrease reflects turnover in temporary balance-account collections, not a decline in underlying service costs. Three recoveries are expiring as two integrity-program recoveries begin, producing a net $66.3 million reduction in the systemwide revenue requirement. Most classes will receive rate decreases; backbone transportation rates will rise because SDG&E's transmission-integrity costs are allocated entirely to that service.

[SoCalGas Advice Letter 6682-GSoCalGas Advice Letter 6682-G.pdf4 MBdownload-circle](https://www.calregulatory.com/content/files/2026/08/SoCalGas-Advice-Letter-6682-G.pdf "Download")

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/36/77/3677b301-4c92-43b7-8e2f-c7265d6b0b59/content/images/2026/08/iterograph_Wed-Aug-05-2026--3-.png)